December 2nd 2017

  Buy Issue 3010

Articles from this issue:

EDITORIAL Turnbull redefines terms of marriage vote

CANBERRA OBSERVED Turnbull is running on empty as margin shrinks

GENDER POLITICS Northern Territory proposes recognising fluid genders

ENVIRONMENT Sea levels are not on the rise: research

NATIONAL AFFAIRS Our clinging to the fringe is stultifying development

FREEDOM Where to now after the marriage redefinition vote?

EDUCATION Unions and the ALP have gutted the curriculum

ECONOMICS The West faces tests of its own resilience

CULTURE The mysterious birth of technology

DRUGS AND SOCIETY Addiction and the cultural repression of spiritual values

OPINION Don't stand by as the fight for freedom begins

LITERATURE Britain's Kazuo Ishiguro a worthy Nobel laureate

HUMOUR Whispers from court side

MUSIC Funny tones: Playing it for a laugh

CINEMA Murder on the Orient Express: First-class mayhem

BOOK REVIEW Disentangling the free-market fraud

BOOK REVIEW Not inscrutible, just ambitious


Books promotion page

Murder on the Orient Express: First-class mayhem

by Symeon J. Thompson

News Weekly, December 2, 2017

Murder, mystery, fine dining and first-class travel, 1930s style. Welcome aboard the Orient Express for Kenneth Branagh’s lavish all-star adaptation of Agatha Christie’s classic mystery Murder on the Orient Express.

Hercule Poirot (Kenneth Branagh) is intending to take a break in Istanbul, after solving a potentially explosive case in Jerusalem, when he is urgently called back to London, requiring him to change his plans and find a berth on the fully booked Orient Express. Luckily, his friend Bouc (Tom Bateman), director of the Orient Express, is also travelling and is able to find him a spot.

Poirot is looking forward to relaxing on the journey, reading Dickens and enjoying the fine food and wine, when the train is derailed by an avalanche and a murder is discovered. Everyone is a suspect, and so Poirot must use his “little grey cells” to solve the case before the police get involved, to save the passengers and the company the distress and bad publicity of being linked to a murder.

Agatha Christie is rightly called the “Queen of Crime”, but her work and her genius is often underrated. Raymond Chandler was famously critical, arguing that Christie and her ilk of Golden Age Crime Writers, like Dorothy L. Sayers, were dull and lacking in humanity, preferring to create a literary puzzle for the reader to solve, one that was far removed from everyday life. He praised them as “incomparably the best dull writers in the world”, who at least made the setting seem real, unlike the Hollywood artificiality of the Americans who aped them. But his preference was for Dashiell Hammett, the hard-boiled poet whose detectives are open to using their brawn as well as their brains to solve cases and right wrongs.

But Chandler’s distinction is as artificial as his own stories. While it’s true that the English school can seem little more than a literary crossword puzzle, it is nonetheless driven by the same forces as all detective stories. As Chandler, and G.K. Chesterton before him, point out, detective stories are tales of knight-errantry in modern dress and modern environs. They are tied to the poetry of civilisation, of cities and towns and technology, and have at their heart a desire to illuminate the darkness by bringing to light those who fracture the order of the world by committing crimes.

Christie’s writing style is as allusive and minimalist as a line drawing, painting the scene and the characters only as much is as necessary, leaving the rest to the reader’s imagination. In this respect it resembles those other great popular works of fairy and folktales and the ways in which those stories leave details to the storyteller. This creates fertile ground for adaptations, adaptations that are then free to deepen or, as is popular now, twist the story to suit the ends of the adapter.

As with his superb versions of Shakespeare and his enchanting Cinderella, Branagh prefers to take the first option, adding depths by asking why and why again, changing things only to add to the story without changing its meaning.

However, the depths he adds are slight when compared with the astonishing richness and nuance of the David Suchet series, especially with regards to this story. The Suchet series homes in on Christie’s regular allusions to Poirot as a practising Catholic who not only disapproves of murder but also believes in the impact of sin. While Branagh mentions Poirot’s desire for order and opposition to evil, such mentions have none of the tragic power of watching an agonised, rosary-clutching Poirot contemplating what he should do. Moreover, the Suchet version achingly depicts the effects of murder upon a murderer, even one who believes himself entirely justified.

These depths go to the heart of Christie’s enduring genius. She may not have written gargantuan volumes of Proustian psychology, but her insights into human nature remain keen and insightful. For Christie the “whodunit” always turns on the “whydunit”, and as a result motive comes to the fore. In her case, the power of the passions and how they can overrule our reason and our very humanity.

Christie focuses on the individual and the impact their choices have, thus making of her mysteries a sort of modern-day morality plays.

Nonetheless, Branagh’s film is a beautifully shot and enjoyable romp at the cinema. But for a much more powerful and affecting version, seek out the masterful series starring David Suchet.

Symeon J. Thompson is a member of the Film Critics’ Circle of Australia (FCCA).

All you need to know about
the wider impact of transgenderism on society.
TRANSGENDER: one shade of grey, 353pp, $39.99

Join email list

Join e-newsletter list

Your cart has 0 items

Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers

Trending articles

COVER STORY Murray-Darling Basin Plan based on debunked science

NATIONAL AFFAIRS Cardinal Pell's appeal to go to High Court

RELIGIOUS FREEDOM ABC survey finds majority agree there is unfair discrimination against religious Australians

COVER STORY Extinction Rebellion: So, it's goodnight to us and a big welcome to mega-bucks

South Park Calls Out Transgender Takeover of Women's Sports

COVER STORY Greta Thunberg: she's not doing it all on her own

RURAL AFFAIRS Queensland Labor punishes farmers to placate UNESCO

© Copyright 2017
Last Modified:
April 4, 2018, 6:45 pm