January 31st 2015


  Buy Issue 2940
Qty:

Articles from this issue:

CANBERRA OBSERVED Is time running out for Tony Abbott?

QUEENSLAND STATE ELECTION Choice facing Queensland voters on January 31

NATIONAL AFFAIRS Will Australia strengthen country-of-origin labelling laws?

GREAT THINKERS What Edmund Burke has to say to the modern world

SOCIETY Fatherlessness linked to increased risk of child abuse

LIFE ISSUES Assassinations should be 'safe, legal and rare'

LIFE ISSUES Shocking figures on Holland's euthanasia-fest

EDITORIAL Greek elections new threat to eurozone

EUROPE 
Economic crisis polarises European politics

EUROPE Paris attack underscores a deeper malaise

UNITED STATES Dismay and outrage at Obama's Cuba policy

CHINA Flood of Chinese 'black money' distorts property market

FOREIGN AFFAIRS Behind Sri Lanka's vote for change

CULTURE What is the point of criticism?

BOOK REVIEW French sanctuary for endangered Jews

BOOK REVIEW Quaker forger who poisoned his mistress

Books promotion page

survey link

FONT SIZE:

CULTURE
What is the point of criticism?


by Symeon J. Thompson

News Weekly, January 31, 2015

A great critic is a moralist who strolls among books. Don Colacho

It can be a messy business being a critic, as one has to balance personal taste with objective assessment. This messiness can come to the fore when there are awards coming up. 

As my byline says, I am a member of the Film Critics Circle of Australia (FCCA). The voting has just finished for the annual awards, and the ceremony is coming up. 

There was a good range of films to pick from this year, with comedies, sci-fi, thrillers, horror stories, and war movies all represented. Some of the films have even been commercially successful and are doing well overseas. 

Here are some examples: 

The Babadook is a psychological horror film about a struggling widowed mother and her troubled son, that William Friedkin, the director of The Exorcist, has declared one of the most terrifying films ever made. 

Predestination was adapted by the Spierig Brothers from a short story by Robert Heinlein about time-travelling cops trying to stop a terrorist called the Fizzle Bomber. It’s a high-brow sci-fi thriller that has been tautly crafted.

The Rover is the latest film from David Michod, of Animal Kingdom fame. This time he’s written a post-apocalyptic drama with Guy Pearce as a very angry and determined man, and Robert Pattinson as a crook whose brother leaves him to die.

Felony is an elegant and restrained thriller about a cop who clips a bike-riding kid and then lies about it. The movie shows his struggle with his conscience and his struggle with the ruthless older cop who helps him, while another detective wants to find out the truth. 

Then there’s Tracks, the biopic about Robyn Davidson’s trek across Australia with camels; Charlie’s Country, Rolf de Heer’s, typically political take on the Northern Territory intervention, but with the superb David Gulpilil as Charlie; These Final Hours, a redemptive drama about the end of the world; I, Frankenstein, a supernatural thriller inspired by Mary Shelley; and 52 Tuesdays, the “coming of age” story of a girl whose mother is undergoing gender-realignment surgery. 

The standout films, for me, were The Water Diviner and Healing. These films were simple in their themes, and traditional — dare I say “human” — in their understanding of things. They have a clear moral compass, but one that is aware that life as lived doesn’t always align with that compass, and that mercy is needed for justice to flourish. 

The Water Diviner is a beautiful film about a man, Joshua Connor (played by Russell Crowe, who also directed), who travels to Gallipoli to find his lost sons after World War I. While there, he becomes involved with a Turkish widow with a bright young son who’s in need of a father. It shows a rich understanding of how war is terrible, but can still be necessary, and how it is possible for different cultures to interact without compromise or conflict. 

Healing takes place in a minimum-security prison farm in Victoria. Matt Perry (Hugo Weaving) starts a new program for prisoners where they assist with the rehabilitation of injured birds of prey. It is a simple film and an elegant one. There is no grand drama in it, only the drama of a man, Viktor Khadem (Don Hany), coming to terms with his life — the choices he has made and the way he has failed — as he takes charge of an injured wedge-tailed eagle to aid its recovery. 

Criticism is the blending of different perceptions into a hopefully coherent whole. It involves reasoning and feeling, observing and reflecting. When it is theorised about, it tends to become overly political, and loses its role as a social conscience, becoming instead an instrument of irreligious dogma.

There are a series of reasonably objective standards that can be used when judging the craftsmanship of a work of art. At the very least, these standards provide a way to categorise a work of art and see what it’s trying to do, to place it within a context, and assess it against similar pieces. 

Also, despite the protests of some, it is possible to assess the morality of a work of art. But to do this requires a great deal of sensitivity and knowledge — of art and morality. It is not enough to make a declaration based on hearsay or a gut reaction to themes or scenes.

The trick with criticism, and all such subjective judgements, is to recognise the craftsmanship, while also recognising if it is to one’s taste, but, most of all, to find the truth of the work. 

Every one of us, being made in the image and likeness of God, provides us with a glimpse of God. Likewise, “Every work of art speaks to us of God. No matter what it says.” — Don Colacho.

Symeon J. Thompson is a member of the Film Critics Circle of Australia (FCCA).




























Join email list

Join e-newsletter list


Your cart has 0 items



Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers



Trending articles

NATIONAL AFFAIRS Cardinal rebuts commission's 'Get Pell' campaign

COVER STORY Anti-discrimination law validates Safe Schools

U.S. AFFAIRS First Brexit, now Trump: it's the economy, stupid!

INDUSTRY AND ENVIRONMENT Wikileaks reveals U.S, funding behind anti-coal campaign

COVER STORY QUT discrimination case exposes Human Rights Commission failings

FOREIGN AFFAIRS How the left whitewashed Fidel Castro

ANALYSIS What is possible to a Trump Whitehouse



News and views from around the world

Frequently asked questions about section 18C (Simon Breheny)

Chilean legislators kill explicit sex-ed program (LifeSite News)

France to ban people with Down syndrome from smiling (The Huffington Post)

Child abuse and family structure: What is the evidence telling us (Family First NZ)

Woolworths beats ACCC supplier mistreatment case (Eli Greenblat)

Australia set to ride the quantum computing wave (Science in Public)

Weatherill warns states could introduce carbon prices (Rosie Lewis)

Green-left legerdemain doesn't make religion relevant (Fr James Grant)

Mass murderer Castro dies unpunished (Augusto Zimmermann)

The rise of political correctness (Angelo Codevilla)



























© Copyright NewsWeekly.com.au 2011
Last Modified:
December 2, 2016, 2:36 pm