November 22nd 2008

  Buy Issue 2793

Articles from this issue:

EDITORIAL: How Barack Obama won

CANBERRA OBSERVED: How long will Malcolm Turnbull last?

NATIONAL SECURITY: Executed Bali bombers hailed as martyrs

HUMAN RIGHTS: Beijing's butcher is granted Australian visa

ENVIRONMENT: Arctic melting: don't spoil a good story with the facts

FINANCIAL MARKETS: Regulatory proposals being put to Obama

OPINION: The West's long-running economic malaise

HEALTH CARE: Australian medicine's middle way

AUSTRALIAN POLITICS: A successful conservative party ready to rebuild

RULE OF LAW: The perils of a politicised judiciary

NATIONAL AFFAIRS: Assessing the Australian Christian Lobby

POPULATION: The economic consequences of abortion

MEDIA: The facts behind the 1949 coal strike

AS THE WORLD TURNS: Toxic melamine in the food chain in China / African-Americans from victimhood to responsibility

Abandoning the old and sick (letter)

Institutional corruption in our schools (letter)

Absurd expectations about Obama (letter)

BOOKS: THE FAMILY: Power, Politics and Fundamentalism's Shadow Elite, by Jeff Sharlet

Books promotion page

survey link


Abandoning the old and sick (letter)

by Dr Lucy G. Sullivan

News Weekly, November 22, 2008

On reading of Baroness Mary Warnock's opinion ("Old and sick have a duty to die", News Weekly, October 11, 2008) that the elderly with dementia are "wasting" the lives of those who care (in both senses) for them, one wonders how someone with so little understanding of the human heart can claim to be an ethicist.

Does she not understand that the children, siblings, grandchildren, nieces and nephews of the senile elderly are still bound to them by ties of deep and lasting affection, no less real than when they were in the prime of life, and that they are part of their on-going self-perception?

More than once I have heard someone say, of such circumstances, "I was not ready to let her go."

Contrast Lady Warnock's attitude with that of a Japanese doctor writing about the treatment of patients with dementia who attended a day-care facility. He (or she) pointed out the inappropriateness of pressure put on them to regain their normal mental faculties.

As he said, we do not expect an 80-year-old to run up stairs, jog or climb a tree as if still a mere 60-year-old, and we do not regard our care as a failure if we cannot train them up to these feats again.

Just as we accept their physical frailty, so we should accept their mental frailty as a natural accompaniment of ageing.

When the patients were not constantly badgered to perform feats of memory now beyond them (primarily of short-term memory), their family carers reported that they were happier and more placid, and apparent personality changes in the direction of irritability disappeared.

Despite their inability to engage with the recent past, they typically retained their life-long values and concerns - whether with peace, the environment or vintage cars. They were still, essentially, themselves.

Locked into her rationalism, Lady Warnock still has a lot to learn.

Dr Lucy G. Sullivan,
Windsor, NSW

Join email list

Join e-newsletter list

Your cart has 0 items

Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers

Trending articles

NATIONAL AFFAIRS Cardinal rebuts commission's 'Get Pell' campaign

COVER STORY Anti-discrimination law validates Safe Schools

U.S. AFFAIRS First Brexit, now Trump: it's the economy, stupid!

INDUSTRY AND ENVIRONMENT Wikileaks reveals U.S, funding behind anti-coal campaign

COVER STORY QUT discrimination case exposes Human Rights Commission failings

FOREIGN AFFAIRS How the left whitewashed Fidel Castro

ANALYSIS What is possible to a Trump Whitehouse

News and views from around the world

19-year-old homeschooled pro-lifer wins Ontario election by landslide (Lianne Laurence)

Trump makes right choice for education secretary (National Review)

Transgender conformity (Katherine Kersten)

Sex education programs do not reduce teen pregnancy or STI rates (Philippa Taylor)

Photographer who captured Safe Schools founder harassing bystander shuts down business (Frank Chung)

Is the global middle class here to stay? (Samuel Rines)

Donald Trump could end America's new feudalism (Joel Kotkin)

It just got easier to find the perpetrators of Stalin's purges (David Filipov)

Castro's death eradicate bacillus of old-style Marxism (Gerald Warner)

Labor MP Terri Butler in QUT race case apology (Geoff Chambers)

© Copyright 2011
Last Modified:
December 2, 2016, 2:36 pm