January 20th 2007

  Buy Issue 2747

Articles from this issue:

EDITORIAL: Bushfire crisis: a state of denial

AUSTRALIAN CONSTITUTION: High Court strikes blow against states' rights

CANBERRA OBSERVED: Kevin Rudd - a more formidable Opposition leader?

NATIONAL AFFAIRS: Government's challenges over AWB-Iraq saga

QUARANTINE: Government to permit NZ apples into Australia

SCHOOLS: Trojan horse in Classical Studies curriculum

STRAWS IN THE WIND: South Pacific blues / Diamonds are an African's worst friend / Modern Madama Melbas / Putin's gambit / The Balibo Five and all that

FILM CLASSIFICATION: Australia's pornography industry suffers setback

ABORTION: Suffering in silence no more

CINEMA: Faithful re-telling of the Christmas story

Pope's back-flip on Turkey (letter)

Lack of Darfur coverage (letter)

Discarding safeguards to pursue human cloning (letter)

BOOKS: GENOCIDE: A History, by William D. Rubinstein


Books promotion page

Discarding safeguards to pursue human cloning (letter)

by John Glancy

News Weekly, January 20, 2007

The current debate on embryonic cloning for the extraction of stem cells is one we shouldn’t be having. It is premature.

Over many years we have established progressive methods of testing new drugs, vaccines, procedures, etc. This is no accident. It is necessary to prove as far as possible that a new discovery is reasonably effective and safe before it is applied to human beings.

It is also important not to generate too much false hope. Such testing is sequential and may involve test tubes and petri dishes and a range of animals.

We are told that stem cells might cure diabetes, Alzheimer's disease, spinal injuries, organ failure. The list seems endless.

Our experience with medical science should teach us at least two things. Firstly, many things that we wouldn’t have believed possible can be accomplished and, secondly, we should proceed by the well-established route, briefly outlined above, because we have had disasters in the past and no doubt have avoided other disasters through proper testing.

Have we any evidence that we are ready for human testing? So far, the media have not shown us one animal that has had its spinal injury reversed; one mouse that has its diabetes cured; or one rabbit in which brain cells have been caused to grow in the correct place.

If stem cells can be made to grow into basal ganglia cells and thereby cure Parkinson's Disease, or into any other tissue, it will be necessary to demonstrate that growth can be turned off at the appropriate moment or the cure could prove to be as bad as the disease.

We have been shown no evidence of any of this.

Surely, it would be safer to follow the established protocols and demonstrate that these things can be achieved in animals before they are tried on suffering human beings.

Victorian Liberal Senator Kay Patterson, one of the drafters of the Bill (recently passed by both the Senate and the House of Representatives), has herself been quoted as saying that it will take 20 years for the value of this research to be known.

Why have this divisive debate now? Would it not be better to follow the established rules and have the scientists come back and show what can be achieved without harm in animals before embarking on human studies?

If the system is short-circuited and disasters occur in humans, who will accept responsibility?

If function can be restored in animals, the debate will be easy. If not, there will be no need for moral judgements.

(Dr) John Glancy,
South Perth, WA

Join email list

Join e-newsletter list

Your cart has 0 items

Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers

Trending articles

SAME-SEX MARRIAGE Memo to Shorten, Wong: LGBTIs don't want it

COVER STORY Shorten takes low road to defeat marriage plebiscite

COVER STORY Reaper mows down first child in the Low Countries

SAME-SEX MARRIAGE Kevin Andrews: defend marriage on principles

COVER STORY Bill Shorten imposes his political will on the nation

CANBERRA OBSERVED Coalition still gridlocked despite foreign success

ENVIRONMENT More pseudo science from climate

News and views from around the world

Menzies, myth and modern Australia (Jonathan Pincus)

China’s utterly disgraceful human-rights record

Japan’s cure for childlessness: a robot (Marcus Roberts)

SOGI laws: a subversive response to a non-existent problem (James Gottry)

Shakespeare, Cervantes and the romance of the real (R.V. Young)

That’s not funny: PC and humour (Anthony Sacramone)

Refugees celebrate capture of terror suspect

The Spectre of soft totalitarianism (Daniel Mahoney)

American dream more dead than you thought (Eric Levitz)

Think the world is overcrowded: These 10 maps show why you’re wrong (Max Galka)

© Copyright NewsWeekly.com.au 2011
Last Modified:
November 14, 2015, 11:18 am