November 4th 2000

  Buy Issue 2595

Articles from this issue:

United States: Clinton’s legacy to determine U.S. presidential poll

Editorial: Telstra’s infrastructure - public service

Agriculture: Apples - who’s fooling whom?

Canberra Observed: Whitlam's apologia on East Timor role

National Affairs: Economic conversion for Democrats' leader?

Taxation: Why the attack on family trusts?

Telecommunications Inquiry: Telstra's country services deficient - TSI report

The Media


Straws in the Wind

The courts and commercialised medicine

Drugs: Needle exchange programs - the shocking reality

Family: Medical professor endorses the condom culture

Society: Markets and morals

Books promotion page

The courts and commercialised medicine

by Helen Spring

News Weekly, November 4, 2000
Medicine's 2000-year-old Hippocratic tradition - codified in the Medical Code of Ethics - may be on the wane, but economic rationalism could deliver the coup de grace.

The first directive in this code is "First do no harm - Primum non nocere".

Second comes: "Listen to the story, 'ere yet ye construct the history." That is, the facts before the conclusions. Only by listening to the patient can we discover the nature and origin of the affliction. The doctor is then able to understand and help the patient find the remedy.

Now, it seems, listening to the patient is discouraged by insidious propaganda and the veiled promotion of medication to dull the symptoms.

In America, the medical profession is failing in its duty of care to patients. Many doctors have become hirelings of managed care. Many are becoming cosy with pharmaceutical firms. The fight to defend patients has been left to lawyers. Class actions are on the increase.

For example, following successful litigation against the tobacco industry, lawyer Richard Scruggs filed a suit against Aetna, one of the largest managed care businesses in America. Other high profile lawyers are also suing managed care companies (Fortune, November 8, 1999).

In one widely-reported action, lawyers claimed that "Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder" (ADHD) is an invented syndrome designed to fuel the sale of psycho-stimulant drugs." (The Australian, September 26, 2000). According to The Bulletin (October 24, 2000), "two class actions have been brought against Novartis, the manufacturer of Ritalin, the American Psychiatric Association and CHADD, a parents' support group, alleging fraud and conspiracy in the over-promotion of ADHD and Ritalin."

Conflicts of interest?

As such legal actions demonstrate, patients need to be aware of potential conflicts of interest in medicine. They also need to watch closely politics in medicine, because politics may influence the treatment patients receive.

Take, for example, a recent situation: three medical organisations - the Australian Medical Association, the National Association of Practising Psychiatrists (NAPP) and the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists (RANZCP) united to defend a small group of vulnerable patients, victims of a Medicare anomaly (Item 319) - reported previously in News Weekly - which restricts access to intensive psychotherapy.

It is now believed that the RANZCP has withdrawn from collaborating with the other two bodies.

Although apparently only of esoteric interest (to the patients, their families and the doctors who treat them) the issue has wider ramifications. The outcome is being watched closely by medical and other interested parties because it has great symbolic significance.

Leaving such a small group of patients undefended would signal that the road to American-style market-driven medicine is wide open.

If this is the case, then Australians may follow Americans and turn to lawyers. Will Item 319 be the first such Australian class action?

Join email list

Join e-newsletter list

Your cart has 0 items

Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers

Trending articles

GENDER POLITICS Family Court washes hands of gender-dysphoric kids

COVER STORY Loy Yang just latest critical asset to go offshore

EDITORIAL Behind the power shift in the Middle East

CANBERRA OBSERVED Freedom of religion just an afterthought?


COVER STORY Blackouts due to closure of coal-fired power stations

POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY The Four Ideologies of the 21st century: Transgenderism, Libertarianism, cultural and Economic, and Radical Environmentalism

© Copyright 2017
Last Modified:
March 16, 2017, 10:40 am