July 22nd 2006

  Buy Issue 2736

Articles from this issue:

CANBERRA OBSERVED: Costello stays on ... for the time being

EDITORIAL: China: let the truth be told

ECONOMY: ABS report card on Australia's economy

NATIONAL AFFAIRS: Liberals turning to Whitlam-style centralism

AGRICULTURE: Tax breaks for wealthy hurting agriculture

INTERNET FILTERING: Coonan's cash buys a dud

STRAWS IN THE WIND: In days of old, when knights were bold / Out of the mouths of babes and sucklings / When the music stopped / The never-ending blood feud / Keeping the lid on our schools

CULTURE WARS: Is it too late to save our civilisation?

SCHOOLS: Time to teach proper history

OPINION: The Muslim problem facing Australia

MEDICAL SCIENCE: Media hype over cloning and embryo stem cells

MEDIA: Time to evict Channel Ten's 'Big Brothel'

Adoption fears (letter)

Aboriginal tragedy (letter)

Sexual integrity and Big Brother (letter)

BOOKS: Laurence Rees, AUSCHWITZ: The Nazis and the 'Final Solution' / THE NAZIS: A Warning from History


Books promotion page

Media hype over cloning and embryo stem cells

by Babette Francis

News Weekly, July 22, 2006
The media insists that legalising human cloning and experimentation on embryonic stem cells will lead to miraculous cures for spinal-cord injury, Parkinson's Disease and Alzheimer's. Babette Francis looks at the evidence.

The media have exposed the fraudulent claims of Korea's Hwang Woo-suk of producing human "clones" and his coercion of women to donate hundreds of eggs. But they have given no attention to the more cruel frauds of using disabled people such as Christopher Reeves, Michael J. Fox and Victoria's wheelchair-bound Gary Allsop to promote embryonic stem-cell research which is going nowhere and which causes tumours.

The exploitation of the late US President Ronald Reagan's widow Nancy was particularly fraudulent as scientists know stem cells are not effective in treating Alzheimer's.

Killing human embryos

Many journalists fail to distinguish between stem cells derived from killing human embryos - embryonic stem cells (ESCs) - and stem cells derived from ethical sources such as cord blood, cord linings, and adult tissues, collectively known as adult stem cells (ASCs). They portray the "religious right" as being anti-science, when all the cures and treatments have come from ASCs and there is not even a clinical trial in humans using ESCs.

Other journalists use the Federal Government's ban on cloning to criticise the Prime Minister. Robyn Riley recently wrote a story headlined "What hope for the sufferers, Mr Howard? Brain-drain shame" in Melbourne's Sunday Herald Sun (June 25, 2006), followed by an emotive story about researchers leaving Australia, and the plight of those suffering from Parkinson's, heart disease, etc.

Do journalists like Riley not have access to the internet from which they could learn about 70 diseases, including heart-muscle disease, being treated by ASCs (stemcellresearch.org), while ESCs have produced nothing but hype and tumours?

"Clones" are produced by a process known as somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) whereby the nucleus is removed from a woman's egg and replaced with the nucleus from a tissue cell from the patient. The resultant cell is not a true clone because the cytoplasm and mitochondria surrounding the nucleus are still foreign tissue from the woman who donated the egg. Embryonic stem cells are hard to control besides having a tendency to develop tumours (teratomas).

There is no excuse for journalists to ignore the successful work, conducted at Griffith University Adult Stem Cell Centre, by Prof. Alan Mackay-Sim and colleagues. Dozens of patients with various genetic diseases have had their stem cells collected from the back of their noses for research. No human embryos have been destroyed. The Griffith's team has used ASCs to treat Parkinson's Disease in rats and is planning primate trials. If all goes well, human trials will follow.

Cloning advocate, Prof. Alan Trounson, admits cloning is not about therapies for Parkinson's or spinal injury, and is limited to the modest research goal of creating patient-specific stem cells‚ for studying disease and developing drugs.

But the Griffith researchers have already achieved "patient-specific stem cells" superior to anything cloning could make, since they are free of the genetic damage inherent in cloning. These adult stem-cells are easily obtained from patients with any disease, readily transformed into the required cell type (brain, muscle, kidney, liver) and useful for genetic study of the disease and development of effective drugs. Prof. Mackay-Sim told the Lockhart Inquiry: "It is probable that such stem cell lines as these will render therapeutic cloning irrelevant and impractical."

Recently, Channel 10 aired a report of paralysed rats moving their legs after treatment with ESCs, not realising that better results in rats were achieved years ago using ASCs (Ramon-Cueto, 2000), and that ESCs cannot be used in the human spine due to their tumour-forming tendency. ASCs have now progressed to trials in paralysed humans, as reported in the Journal of Spinal Cord Medicine (June 2006).

Taxpayers' limited money should be spent only on research that is both successful and ethically sound, not on horrors that demand the creation and killing of human embryos, and the exploitation of women to obtain thousands of eggs.

Treasurer Peter Costello is to be commended for refusing to sanction such destructive experimentation. If Victorian Opposition Leader Ted Baillieu took the trouble to study this issue, he could easily challenge Premier Steve Bracks and Treasurer Brumby to a debate on their distorted vision for an ESC research facility.

Bracks is particularly misguided in threatening to break with the federal Human Cloning Prohibition Act 2002 - in which our Parliament voted unanimously to prohibit the creation of cloned human embryos to be destroyed in research.

Nothing has changed since then in the science of cloning – not even in the countries which allow cloning. Bracks has no grounds for claiming that cloning has anything valuable to offer. The hype for cloning is little more than fraud, fairy tales and the exploitation of suffering patients.

  • Babette Francis, B.Sc (Hons), is co-ordinator of Endeavour Forum Inc.

Join email list

Join e-newsletter list

Your cart has 0 items

Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers

Trending articles

SAME-SEX MARRIAGE Memo to Shorten, Wong: LGBTIs don't want it

COVER STORY Shorten takes low road to defeat marriage plebiscite

COVER STORY Reaper mows down first child in the Low Countries

COVER STORY Bill Shorten imposes his political will on the nation

SAME-SEX MARRIAGE Kevin Andrews: defend marriage on principles

CANBERRA OBSERVED Coalition still gridlocked despite foreign success

ENVIRONMENT More pseudo science from climate

News and views from around the world

Menzies, myth and modern Australia (Jonathan Pincus)

China’s utterly disgraceful human-rights record

Japan’s cure for childlessness: a robot (Marcus Roberts)

SOGI laws: a subversive response to a non-existent problem (James Gottry)

Shakespeare, Cervantes and the romance of the real (R.V. Young)

That’s not funny: PC and humour (Anthony Sacramone)

Refugees celebrate capture of terror suspect

The Spectre of soft totalitarianism (Daniel Mahoney)

American dream more dead than you thought (Eric Levitz)

Think the world is overcrowded: These 10 maps show why you’re wrong (Max Galka)

© Copyright NewsWeekly.com.au 2011
Last Modified:
November 14, 2015, 11:18 am