July 17th 2004

  Buy Issue 2686

Articles from this issue:

COVER STORY: Indonesian elections ... and Australia

CANBERRA OBSERVED: Latham affair lifts election temperature

AGRICULTURE: Rural unrest spreads

QUARANTINE BREACH: Exotic disease outbreak threatens Qld citrus industry

INDUSTRY: Singapore recovers on back of manufacturing

FAMILY: Child care - in whose interests?

ARTS & MEDIA: 'The next program contains...'

FILM: AFA calls for ban on 'arthouse smut'

MIDDLE EAST: Can Iraq's interim government end the insurgency?

NUCLEAR WEAPONS: Terrorism marks the end of deterrence

UNITED STATES: Curtains on Camelot

STRAWS IN THE WIND: Skimming administrative fat / What about Uganda? / 17 years of war

Premier Beattie's ethanol 'mania' (letter)

Sugar Package (letter)

Mondragon (letter)

Journalists and Iraq (letter)

BOOKS: George Santayana, by Noël O'Sullivan

BOOKS: Tilting the Playing Field, by Jessica Gavora

OPINION: Time to act on North Korean tyranny

Books promotion page

survey link


Mondragon (letter)

by Dr Peter Hun

News Weekly, July 17, 2004

Dr Race Mathews' talk on "Lessons from Mondragon" (News Weekly, June 5) is, of course, a small summary of part of his book, Jobs of Our Own: Building a Stakeholder Society, but it does convey much of the emphasis and detail of the quite formidable work from which it is drawn.

That emphasis is on co-operative sharing, with a living and thriving example of what it offers in the enterprise of helping to encourage and shape a "distributist" society. But, as I pointed out in my comprehensive review of the book in The Chesterton Review (February-May 1999), it has several flaws amidst its sanguine claims for Mondragon as a superb distributist breakthrough in the modem world.

Of course, co-operative sharing has always been one of the keynotes of fruitful change offered by the more democratic "socialists" such as the Guild Socialists who drew a vision and inspiration from the guilds of the Middle Ages; and it has always been one of the highlights of the distributist thinking in the works of Belloc and Chesterton. But the main emphasis of the mainstream distributist cause has been a decentralist one, with widely distributed property, especially in land.

In an essay, Why I am Not a Socialist, Chesterton pointed out that "individual proprietorship" is more a matter of giving than of collectivist sharing, and he always recognised the more creative and free nature of small farming. There is not much about farming and decentralist ownership in Mathews' stakeholder society. The system embodied in Mondragon seems too centralist and enmeshed with the industrial-capitalist world. It hardly shares the virtues of Schumacher's Small is Beautiful with its "intermediate technology".

Despite praiseworthy attention to co-operation and better status of workers who enjoy the benefits of better pay and involvement in crucial decision-making, Mondragon and the society Mathews would have us see as the "solution" to the profound woes of big capitalism, are not sufficiently different in approaches to industrial reform from the very giant corporations Chesterton and Belloc detested.

The truly distributist society is decentralist and humane, not one that emulates big business. Land reform is its chief goal.

Dr Peter Hunt,
Franklin, Tas

Join email list

Join e-newsletter list

Your cart has 0 items

Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers

Trending articles

NATIONAL AFFAIRS Cardinal rebuts commission's 'Get Pell' campaign

COVER STORY Anti-discrimination law validates Safe Schools

U.S. AFFAIRS First Brexit, now Trump: it's the economy, stupid!

INDUSTRY AND ENVIRONMENT Wikileaks reveals U.S, funding behind anti-coal campaign

COVER STORY QUT discrimination case exposes Human Rights Commission failings

FOREIGN AFFAIRS How the left whitewashed Fidel Castro

ANALYSIS What is possible to a Trump Whitehouse

News and views from around the world

19-year-old homeschooled pro-lifer wins Ontario election by landslide (Lianne Laurence)

Trump makes right choice for education secretary (National Review)

Transgender conformity (Katherine Kersten)

Sex education programs do not reduce teen pregnancy or STI rates (Philippa Taylor)

Photographer who captured Safe Schools founder harassing bystander shuts down business (Frank Chung)

Is the global middle class here to stay? (Samuel Rines)

Donald Trump could end America's new feudalism (Joel Kotkin)

It just got easier to find the perpetrators of Stalin's purges (David Filipov)

Castro's death eradicate bacillus of old-style Marxism (Gerald Warner)

Labor MP Terri Butler in QUT race case apology (Geoff Chambers)

© Copyright NewsWeekly.com.au 2011
Last Modified:
December 2, 2016, 2:36 pm