February 8th 2003


  Buy Issue 2650
Qty:

Articles from this issue:

COVER STORY: Old-growth forests and wildfires

COMMENT: Iraq's last chance to avert war

CANBERRA OBSERVED: Howard turns eyes to NSW poll

HIGH COURT: A further improvement in the High Court

STRAWS IN THE WIND: False Dawn / Iraq another Vietnam? / UN: ideal and reality

AGRICULTURE: Deregulation and low prices see sugar investment collapse

The fatal flaw in economic rationalism (letter)

Why men avoid fatherhood (letter)

Cattle grazing to cut bushfire risk (letter)

Firefighters deserve our thanks (letter)

Canberra's tragedy (letter)

Case against Saddam not established (letter)

Full story (letter)

Cane farmers' survey (letter)

PROFILE: Solzhenitsyn: the conscience of modern society

ASIA: China launches massive infrastructure expansion

VICTORIA: Taxpayers bankroll alternative lifestyles

ASIA: Taiwan's rural finance in trouble

BOOKS: ANSETT: the Collapse, by Geoff Easdown and Peter Wilms

BOOKS: Human Cloning and Human Dignity: The Report of the President's Council on Bioethics

Books promotion page
FONT SIZE:

The fatal flaw in economic rationalism (letter)


by Suryan Chandrasegaran

News Weekly, February 8, 2003
Sir,

I have read the claims Mr Colebatch has been making on behalf of the free market.

He mentioned how free markets had helped improve the living standards of some people in developing countries. However, such improvements can be short-lived. Indonesia, for example, is still paying the price for placing its currency at the mercy of the market. In comparison, communist China maintained government control of its currency and continues to have enviable economic growth.

I was taught the economic rationalist ("ER") theory regarding the perfection of the market for three years at university. This theory relies heavily on unrealistic assumptions.

For example, it assumes that there are no barriers to entry to any markets, including labour markets. If this were true, a factory worker who lost his job today could theoretically work as a doctor tomorrow. If this was a regular occurrence in the real world, the market could quickly eliminate unemployment and reduce poverty.

However, it is ridiculous to rely on ER theory alone to solve real-world problems when its underlying assumptions can never be fulfilled. Other countries, such as the US, realise this and behave rationally. They verbally praise the free market but seek reduction of tariffs and subsidies only in industries or areas which would benefit their own people.

Australia's policy of eliminating our domestic tariffs has been costly. It has decimated large sections of Australian industry and cost jobs. This policy has also resulted in social costs as families disintegrate under financial strain.

The supporters of ER theory in universities, government or business do not directly suffer the consequences of the application of ER theory to the economy. They generally keep their jobs, and their pay usually increases. Australian CEOs have recently shown that even if they lose their jobs, they still receive handsome payouts. It is left to ordinary Australian workers and families to pay the price of "restructuring" as their jobs are eliminated.

I commend Mr Colin Teese for speaking up on behalf of these ordinary Australians against the flawed policies produced by ER theorists.

Suryan Chandrasegaran,
Leongatha, Vic




























Join email list

Join e-newsletter list


Your cart has 0 items



Subscribe to NewsWeekly

Research Papers



Trending articles

COVER STORY Much food for reflection in a single Christmas carol

FOREIGN AFFAIRS The left's whitewash of Fidel Castro

THE MEDIA Greed, ideology generate burst of fake news online

WA LEGISLATION Foetal homicide reform a very small step forward

CANBERRA OBSERVED Coalition limps through year of frustrations

BOOK APPRAISAL Religious incredulity: a most modern virtue

AUSTRALIAN DEVELOPMENT The financial and social costs of cramming ourselves into just five coastal cities



News and views from around the world



























© Copyright NewsWeekly.com.au 2011
Last Modified:
December 2, 2016, 2:36 pm